NFL Week 1 Insights: Breaking Down the Real and the Overreactions
Bill Barnwell analyzes the key performances and overreactions from NFL Week 1, focusing on teams like the Lions, Colts, Dolphins, and Jets.

Ravens' Fourth Down Decision: A Critical Mistake
The Ravens faced a pivotal moment in their game against the Bills. With a fourth-and-2.6 situation, coach John Harbaugh opted to punt, a decision that ultimately cost them the game. Despite having Lamar Jackson and Derrick Henry, two of the league's most dynamic players, Harbaugh chose to trust his defense, which failed to stop Josh Allen. This decision highlights the importance of aggressive play-calling in crucial moments.
Lions' Offensive Struggles: A Cause for Concern
Detroit's offense, which has been a strength in recent years, struggled against the Packers. Jared Goff, who has been efficient with play-action, was less effective in pure dropback situations. The Lions' inability to establish the run game further compounded their problems, leading to a disappointing 27-13 loss.
Bengals' Defense: A Step Forward, But Not There Yet
Cincinnati's defense showed improvement, holding the Browns to 16 points. However, their success was partly due to missed field goals and fortunate interceptions. While it's a positive sign, the Bengals' defense still has a long way to go to be considered elite.
Jets' Run Game: A Bright Spot
The Jets' run game was a highlight in their loss to the Steelers. Justin Fields and the running backs combined for 189 yards and three touchdowns. This performance suggests that the Jets could be a competitive team if they can maintain this level of production.
Aaron Rodgers' Return: Functional, But Not Spectacular
Rodgers' return to MetLife Stadium was solid, but not spectacular. He threw four touchdown passes, but his overall performance was more functional than dominant. The Steelers' run game struggled, which could be a concern moving forward.
Commanders' Run Game: A Dominant Force
Washington's run game was a key factor in their 21-6 victory over the Giants. Rookie Jacory Croskey-Merritt was particularly impressive, showcasing the Commanders' depth and versatility in the backfield.
Colts' Offense: A Surprising Performance
Indianapolis' offense was efficient, scoring on every possession against the Dolphins. Daniel Jones was smooth and reliable, but it remains to be seen if this level of performance can be sustained against tougher competition.
Dolphins' Offense: A Disappointing Start
Miami's offense struggled mightily, with Tua Tagovailoa having one of the worst games of his career. The Dolphins' inability to handle pressure and their poor decision-making were key factors in their loss.
Bo Nix: Struggling to Make the Leap
Broncos' quarterback Bo Nix had a tough outing against the Titans, failing to make a significant impact. His struggles against pressure and inability to generate big plays were concerning, raising questions about his development.
Conclusion
Week 1 of the NFL season provided plenty of excitement and surprises. While some teams showed promise, others have significant areas to address. As the season progresses, it will be interesting to see which teams can build on their early performances and which ones will need to make adjustments.