The Best NHL Draft Picks Ever: Slot by Slot Analysis

The NHL draft has been a cornerstone of hockey history, producing legends and stars who have left an indelible mark on the sport. From the first overall pick to the 224th, every slot has its own story of triumph, disappointment, and legacy. Here’s a deep dive into the best NHL draft picks ever, slot by slot.

1. Mario Lemieux, C, Pittsburgh Penguins (1984)

Mario Lemieux, often referred to as "Le Magnifique," is arguably the greatest first overall pick in NHL history. Despite a career shortened by injury and illness, Lemieux scored 1,723 points in 915 games, averaging 1.88 points per game—second only to Wayne Gretzky. However, modern stars like Alex Ovechkin, Sidney Crosby, and Connor McDavid have sparked debates about who truly deserves the title of the best No. 1 pick.

2. Marcel Dionne, C, Detroit Red Wings (1971)

The battle for the best No. 2 pick is fierce, with contenders like Evgeni Malkin and Marcel Dionne. Dionne, with 1,771 points in 1,348 games, edges out Malkin due to his incredible goal-scoring ability and longevity. Dionne’s legacy as a King, despite the team’s struggles, cements his place as the quintessential No. 2 pick.

3. Scott Niedermayer, D, New Jersey Devils (1991)

Scott Niedermayer’s smooth skating and offensive prowess made him a key player on four Stanley Cup-winning teams. His Conn Smythe and Norris Trophy wins solidify his status as the best No. 3 pick, though Leon Draisaitl is quickly building a case to challenge this title.

4. Steve Yzerman, C, Detroit Red Wings (1983)

Steve Yzerman, known as "The Captain," led the Red Wings to three Stanley Cups and is seventh in career points with 1,755. His leadership and clutch performances make him the best No. 4 pick, though Cale Makar’s rising career could one day challenge this legacy.

5. Jaromir Jagr, RW, Pittsburgh Penguins (1990)

Jaromir Jagr’s career is one of the most storied in NHL history. With 1,921 points, Jagr is second only to Gretzky in all-time scoring. His longevity, skill, and unique style make him the undisputed best No. 5 pick.

61. Wayne Simmonds, RW, Los Angeles Kings (2007)

Wayne Simmonds, known as "Mr. 61," is the most successful player drafted at No. 61. With 263 goals and 526 points, Simmonds’ consistency and physical play make him a standout in this slot.

Conclusion

The NHL draft has produced countless legends, each leaving their mark on the game. From Mario Lemieux to Wayne Simmonds, these players have defined their draft slots and cemented their legacies in hockey history. As the NHL continues to evolve, new stars will emerge, but the legends of the past will always be remembered as the best of the best.