The Ravens' Kicking Dilemma

For over a decade, the Baltimore Ravens have enjoyed the luxury of having Justin Tucker, one of the most reliable kickers in NFL history, as their go-to option. However, recent allegations of sexual misconduct against Tucker have thrown the team into a state of uncertainty as they approach the free agency negotiating window.

Allegations and Investigations

According to the Baltimore Banner, Tucker has been accused of inappropriate behavior by 16 massage therapists from eight different spas and wellness centers. While Tucker has publicly denied these allegations, the NFL is currently investigating the matter. The Ravens have stated that they will await the conclusion of the investigation before making any decisions regarding Tucker's future.

Contingency Plans

In light of these developments, the Ravens are exploring their options in both free agency and the upcoming NFL Draft. General Manager Eric DeCosta and head coach John Harbaugh have acknowledged that the team is evaluating potential kickers. "I'd say the kicker position would have been a priority no matter what," Harbaugh said.

Free Agency Options

The Ravens could look to veteran kickers such as Nick Folk, Matt Prater, or Eddy Pineiro to fill the void if Tucker does not return. However, they may also choose to wait until after the draft to sign a free agent, allowing them to preserve potential compensatory picks for the following season.

Draft Prospects

The 2025 NFL Draft presents an opportunity for the Ravens to secure a young kicker. The team has 11 projected picks and has never drafted a kicker in its 29-year history. Potential candidates include Florida State's Ryan Fitzgerald, Arizona's Tyler Loop, Miami's Andres Borregales, and Pittsburgh's Ben Sauls. Borregales is currently the top-rated kicker in the draft class according to ESPN analyst Mel Kiper Jr.

Evaluating Talent

The Ravens have a strong track record of identifying talented kickers without using draft picks. They’ve signed three undrafted kickers—Graham Gano in 2008, Tucker in 2012, and Wil Lutz in 2016—all of whom went on to become Pro Bowlers. Senior special teams coach Randy Brown will play a crucial role in evaluating the prospects.

The Challenge of Rookie Kickers

Rookie kickers have historically lower field goal success rates compared to league averages. Over the past 10 seasons, rookies made 81.8% of their field goals, below the league average of 84.4%. However, the Ravens' proficiency in special teams could help a new kicker succeed.

Tucker’s Legacy

Justin Tucker’s legacy with the Ravens is undeniable. Since joining the team in 2012, he has earned seven Pro Bowl invitations and five first-team All-Pro honors. His 89.1% success rate on field goals is the best in NFL history. However, at 35 years old and coming off a season where he missed a career-worst 10 kicks, questions about his future performance have arisen.

Looking Ahead

The Ravens may face a difficult decision regarding Tucker’s future. Whether they choose to stick with him or move on, the team’s ability to adapt and find a reliable kicker will be crucial for their success in the upcoming season.